online prescription solutions
online discount medstore
pills online
buy lorazepam without prescription
xanax for sale
buy xanax without prescription
buy ambien without prescription
ambien for sale
buy modafinil without prescription
buy phentermine without prescription
modafinil for sale
phentermine for sale
lorazepam for sale
buy lexotan without prescription
bromazepam for sale
xenical for sale
buy stilnox without prescription
valium for sale
buy prosom without prescription
buy mefenorex without prescription
buy sildenafil citrate without prescription
buy adipex-p without prescription
librium for sale
buy restoril without prescription
buy halazepam without prescription
cephalexin for sale
buy zoloft without prescription
buy renova without prescription
renova for sale
terbinafine for sale
dalmane for sale
buy lormetazepam without prescription
nobrium for sale
buy klonopin without prescription
priligy dapoxetine for sale
buy prednisone without prescription
buy aleram without prescription
buy flomax without prescription
imovane for sale
adipex-p for sale
buy niravam without prescription
seroquel for sale
carisoprodol for sale
buy deltasone without prescription
buy diazepam without prescription
zopiclone for sale
buy imitrex without prescription
testosterone anadoil for sale
buy provigil without prescription
sonata for sale
nimetazepam for sale
buy temazepam without prescription
buy xenical without prescription
buy famvir without prescription
buy seroquel without prescription
rivotril for sale
acyclovir for sale
loprazolam for sale
buy nimetazepam without prescription
buy prozac without prescription
mogadon for sale
viagra for sale
buy valium without prescription
lamisil for sale
camazepam for sale
zithromax for sale
buy clobazam without prescription
buy diflucan without prescription
modalert for sale
diflucan for sale
buy alertec without prescription
buy zyban without prescription
buy serax without prescription
buy medazepam without prescription
buy imovane without prescription
mefenorex for sale
lormetazepam for sale
prednisone for sale
ativan for sale
buy alprazolam without prescription
buy camazepam without prescription
buy nobrium without prescription
mazindol for sale
buy mazindol without prescription
buy mogadon without prescription
buy terbinafine without prescription
diazepam for sale
buy topamax without prescription
cialis for sale
buy tafil-xanor without prescription
buy librium without prescription
buy zithromax without prescription
retin-a for sale
buy lunesta without prescription
serax for sale
restoril for sale
stilnox for sale
lamotrigine for sale

Your Smartphone; A Prosecutor’s Best Witness


Witnesses in the United States may choose to exercise their right to “plead the Fifth,” or refuse to answer a question because the response could provide self incriminating evidence of an illegal act. But how strong is this right if a prosecutor is already aware of where a witness was, what they saw, what they heard, and in some ways even what they were thinking at any given time on any given day? I do not refer to torture, truth serums, or the recent accomplishment of Berkeley scientists in creating visual pictures from brain waves. Rather, I refer to smart phones and the growing field of “reality mining” or “mobile phone sensing.”

The Progression of Mobile Phone Technology

Mobile phones had a humble beginning in 1973. Unlike modern iterations, the first mobile phone was bulky, difficult to transport, and had but one function; it allowed you to make a phone call. Technology has rapidly progressed from 1973, and today’s smart phones come rich with functionality through the use of embedded sensors. For example, the Apple iPhone comes equipped with an accelerometer, gyroscope, GPS, digital compass, ambient light detection, and dual microphones and cameras. These sensors give the iPhone the ability to speak, listen, locate, give directions, detect movement etc…  The new iPhone4S also responds to natural language queries.

“Mobile phone sensing” makes use of these digital senses to enable smart phones to become even more dynamic. Dartmouth College’s Smartphone Sensing Group
describes it as “turning the everyday smart phone into a cognitive phone by pushing intelligence to the phone and the computing cloud to make inferences about people’s behavior, surroundings and their life patterns.” The practical applications of this field seem enormous:

  • Researchers at Dartmouth college describe examples such as 1) using accelerometer data to automatically recognize different activities (e.g., running, walking, standing), 2) combining accelerometer data with location estimates from a phone’s GPS to recognize the mode of transportation such as walking, biking, driving, taking a bus or riding the subway and 3) continuously collecting audio from a phone’s microphone to “classify a diverse set of distinctive sounds associated with a particular context or activity in a person’s life, such as using an automated teller machine, being in a particular coffee shop, having a conversation, listening to music, making coffee, and driving.” Amongst a laundry list of other applications, this data can be translated into suggestions for how to avoid traffic, increase social networking, and for personal health care by tracking your physical activity or the number of times you’ve visited your doctor’s office.
  • An Oregon based technology company, Digimarc, has developed an application that uses a mobile phone’s camera and microphone to “detect digital watermarks encoded into magazines, newspapers, packaging and other printed materials, as well as identify songs in music and read QR codes.” Mobile phones can then recognize what it is that a user is looking at or listening to and make personalized suggestions.
  • Sandy Pentland (a leader in the field of mobile phone sensing and director of MIT’s Human Dynamics Laboratory) predicts that mobile phone sensing may be able to give clues to diagnosing depression by detecting changes in speech patterns, or using a phones motion sensors to reveal slight changes in gait, potentially acting as an early indicator of ailments such as Parkinson’s disease.

Smart Phone as a Witness

Yet these examples may not be the limit to what mobile phone sensing may be used for in the future. It seems possible that future criminal (or civil) trials may not need live witnesses so long as the sensor data from an accused individual’s smart phone was admissible as evidence. Before a word was said, it could be known where the individual was, who they were with, what they were looking at, listening to, talking about etc… Not just the day that a crime was committed, but days, weeks, or months in the past. These seem to be the personal experiences that individuals were traditionally allowed to protect to avoid self-incrimination.


The Fifth Amendment is concerned with what an individual must be witness to after a crime is committed, rather than before. Ex ante choices such as planning to commit a crime do not bar a person’s right to avoid self-incrimination. Thus a person who purchases a smart phone in order to utilize the advantages of mobile phone sensing (or for whatever other reason) should not diminish their rights under the Constitution. When we look ex post, the experiences that a phone interprets are the users, the senses that it has are digital extensions of the individuals. Those experiences and senses is what the Fifth Amendment is concerned with and should not be allowed as evidence of a person’s guilt.

About the Author

Blake Davis

Blake Davis is a Staffer for the Columbia Science and Technology Law Review. He is a 2L at Columbia Law School.
  • Business Printing

    Interesting post. Nowadays many of us use smartphone and it is helpful for us. But i don’t know  Smartphone; A Prosecutor’s Best Witness.

blog comments powered by Disqus